The Missing Tool for Tackling Tough Problems: Value-Based Analysis

We live in a world where everyone has an opinion on everything, and far too many of those opinions are formed in about three seconds based on a headline or a tweet. That’s not thinking—that’s reacting. Real thinking, the kind that actually helps you understand complicated issues instead of just picking a side, takes more effort than most people want to give. But if you’re tired of feeling like every difficult conversation turns into a shouting match where nobody learns anything, there’s a better way to approach it. It’s called Value-Based Analysis, and it’s a framework that helps you evaluate issues not just by cherry-picking facts that support what you already believe, but by identifying the principles you care about most and using those as a guide.

What Is Value-Based Analysis?

Value-Based Analysis is a critical-thinking tool that forces you to slow down and examine what’s really driving your position on an issue. Instead of jumping straight to “I agree” or “I disagree,” you take a step back and ask yourself: what values am I prioritizing here? Is it fairness? Freedom? Safety? Responsibility? Most hard issues aren’t hard because there’s one obvious right answer. They’re hard because multiple legitimate values are in conflict with each other, and different people weigh those values differently.

For example, take public health mandates. One person might prioritize personal freedom above all else and oppose mandates on principle. Another person might prioritize community safety and support them. Both people have legitimate values guiding their thinking, but they’re weighing those values differently. Understanding that doesn’t mean you have to agree with the other side, but it does mean you can stop assuming they’re stupid or evil just because they landed on a different conclusion. 

How To Use Value-Based Analysis

Here’s a simple step-by-step process for using this approach when you’re trying to think through a difficult issue:

Step 1: Identify the issue clearly. What exactly are you trying to evaluate? Be specific. Replace “What do I think about education policy?” with something clearer: “Should our school district change its curriculum to include more real-world skills?” 

Step 2: List the core values at play. What principles are relevant here? Common values include fairness, freedom, safety, responsibility, equality, tradition, progress, and community. Write them down. Don’t skip this step (seeing them on paper helps).

Step 3: Rank your values for this specific issue. Which of these values matters most to you in this context? Be honest. You might value freedom highly in general, but maybe in this particular situation, safety takes priority. That’s okay. Context matters.

Step 4: Evaluate the options through your value lens. Now look at the possible positions or solutions and ask: which one best aligns with the values I’ve prioritized? This is where you actually think instead of react.

Step 5: Consider the trade-offs. Every decision involves trade-offs. If you choose Option A because it prioritizes freedom, what does that mean for safety? If you choose Option B because it prioritizes fairness, what does that mean for efficiency? Acknowledging trade-offs doesn’t make you wishy-washy. It makes you realistic.

Dive deeper: For more tips on uncovering the values beneath the argument, check out the essay “Complicating the Narratives” by our Movement Partner Amanda Ripley. 

Why This Matters

Value-Based Analysis won’t magically make everyone agree on everything. That’s not the point. The point is to give yourself a structured way to think through hard issues so you’re making decisions based on what you actually believe in, not just what your social media feed told you to think. It also helps you understand why other people disagree with you, which is useful if you ever want to have a conversation that doesn’t devolve into a screaming match.

When you understand that most disagreements aren’t about facts (they’re about which values people prioritize) you can stop talking past each other and start having real discussions. You might still disagree, but at least you’ll understand why. And that’s a hell of a lot better than what most people are doing right now, which is just yelling into the void and hoping someone on the internet validates them.

Value-Based Analysis is a tool. It takes practice. But if you’re serious about thinking better instead of just feeling confident in your snap judgments, it’s worth the effort.

—Alex Buscemi (abuscemi@buildersmovement.org)

Art by Matthew Lewis

Help Turn Common Ground Into Real Change

In a world where extremists seek to divide for power and profit, Builders take action to unite, create, and bring light to the world. Support the development of new media, tools, and platforms to help us give the power back to the people.

👉 Support the Builders Movement