Editorial
Part of Builders Texas
Should Texas Let Voters Write Their Own Laws?
In over half of the states in the US, when lawmakers won't act, voters can. They gather signatures, put a proposal on the ballot, and decide it themselves. Texans can't. Texas has no statewide citizen-led ballot initiative, which means every law and every constitutional amendment has to start with the legislature.
Yet many of the issues Texans care about most keep stalling at the Capitol. So, how did Texas end up without this tool, would it help, and what could go wrong? Here's the honest case on both sides.
What is a citizen-led ballot initiative?
A ballot initiative lets ordinary citizens propose a new law or constitutional amendment, collect a set number of voter signatures, and put it on the ballot for everyone to decide. A related tool, the veto referendum, lets voters petition to overturn a law the legislature already passed.
Right now, 26 states offer at least one of these tools, including neighbors like Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Colorado. Of those, 18 let citizens propose constitutional amendments directly. People use them, too: in 2024, 18 states had citizen initiatives on the ballot on topics ranging from minimum wage to property taxes to how elections are run.
Texas does have a version of this at the city level. Some Texas cities, including Austin, let residents petition to put local measures on the ballot. This November, Austin voters will decide Prop I, a city charter amendment that got there through a citizen petition drive. But there’s no equivalent process for state laws or the Texas Constitution.
Why doesn’t Texas have them?
The idea to implement citizen-led ballots gained traction in Texas after California's 1978 Prop 13 tax revolt. Gov. Bill Clements promised the legislature in 1979 that he would call a special session if initiative and referendum didn't pass, then failed to deliver. Leading the opposition was a Houston lobbyist named James K. Nance, who represented major corporations like DuPont, Pennzoil, and United Texas Gas Transmission.
Republican primary voters backed the idea seven to one in 1980 and five to one in 1982, but support waned when its main proponent, Senator Walter Magden, retired.
By the mid-1990s, the state GOP had swapped its pro-initiative platform plank for an anti-initiative one, and the push largely stalled.
Today, only the legislature can put a statewide question on the ballot. Because creating an initiative process would itself require a constitutional amendment, the people who would share power are the only ones who can decide to share it. This traps initiative and referendum in a catch 22: the people want citizen-led initiatives, but they can’t create a citizen-led initiative to legalize citizen-led initiatives.
The case for them
Supporters argue that the idea would allow citizens to enact the will of the majority when lawmakers won’t budge.
On several issues, clear majorities of Texans want change that the Legislature hasn't delivered. These include legal medical marijuana with a prescription (79% of Texans are in favor), expanding Medicaid (69%), and background checks on all gun buyers, including private sales (89%).
But even when polls show majority support, these laws fail in a system where a handful of leaders control which bills get a floor vote. Whatever you think of any single policy, the pattern is the point: when voters can't move an issue through their representatives, they have nowhere else to take it.
Supporters also argue that citizen-led initiatives would make lawmakers more accountable. The mere possibility of a ballot initiative pushes legislators to take popular issues seriously, because ignoring voters no longer means the issue disappears.
The case against them
Critics warn that citizen-led initiatives could end up favoring whoever has the most money to spend on campaigns. Deirdre Delisi, a political consultant and the former chief of staff to Gov. Rick Perry, argues: “I think a lot of people may romanticize it as this is pure democracy in action, but I think it really becomes just like, who’s got the biggest pockets.” Because true grassroots efforts often lack the money and organization to collect signatures and run a statewide campaign, the measures that actually reach the ballot can end up reflecting the priorities of whoever can afford to put them there.
Some also worry that measures written without legislative review could be poorly drafted and backfire.
Consider Oregon Measure 110, a citizen-led initiative passed in 2020. Voters decriminalized possession of small amounts of drugs and redirected cannabis tax money toward addiction treatment. But the treatment system was slow to scale up while public drug use and overdoses rose, and in 2024 the legislature recriminalized possession.
According to Jim Henson, the director of the Texas Politics Project at UT Austin: “Voters are asked to do something … that we know they’re not very good at. And that is to have detailed policy knowledge and to make complex judgments and possibly to make a lot of them.”
Where do citizen-led initiatives stand in Texas today?
Giving Texans initiative power would require a constitutional amendment, which means two-thirds of both chambers would have to agree before voters get the final say. Bills keep getting filed: lawmakers introduced one in 2023 and again in 2025 with the Empowering Texans Ballot Initiative Act. Neither reached the floor.
That keeps the issue of citizen-led ballot initiatives squarely in the hands of the people we elect. Reasonable Texans can land on either side of this debate. But it's fair to ask every candidate a simple question: when the people you represent want something and elected officials won't move, whose side are you on?
The midterms are on November 3. Before you vote, find out where the candidates on your ballot stand on giving Texans a direct voice, and look for the ones with the character to answer honestly, even when it's inconvenient for their party.
Need help making sense of the midterms? Click here.
Alex Buscemi can be reached at abuscemi@buildersmovement.org
Art by Matthew Lewis
Keep Reading
5 Policies Trump and a Blue Congress Agree On
5 Thoughts We Have on the Midterms